THE PIRATE’S COOKBOOK · GALLEY EDITION
Steak. Garlic butter. Prawns.
A flexible surf-and-turf plate from Colin’s Aqua Service cooking notes. Choose your steak, keep the prawns simple, and let the sides fit the meal.
Colin’s starting point is straightforward: take the steak from the fridge, pat it dry, season it and cook it with butter or olive oil. For the prawns, he uses frozen shell-on prawns, garlic and butter, sometimes with onions. This is an adaptable cooking guide, not a reconstruction of one particular service.
THE PLATE AT A GLANCE
STEAK · Dry, season, sear
PRAWNS · Thaw safely, garlic, butter
SIDES · Start the slowest part first
Suggested shopping list · 2 servings
These are practical starting estimates, not measured quantities from Colin’s original meal. Adjust for the steak cut, prawn size and appetites.
- 2 steaks, roughly 200–250 g each; choose a cut suitable for pan cooking
- About 250–350 g raw shell-on prawns, frozen or thawed safely
- 2–3 garlic cloves, finely chopped
- 2 tablespoons butter for the prawns; extra butter or a little olive oil for the steak
- Salt and pepper, or your preferred spice blend
- Optional: half an onion, sliced
- Your choice of ready-to-serve sides
01 / Get the prep right
Thaw frozen prawns in the refrigerator in a covered container that catches drips. For faster thawing, keep them in a sealed bag in cold water, change the water regularly and cook immediately after thawing. Follow the package instructions, including any requirement to remove vacuum packaging. Never thaw seafood on the counter. Drain and pat dry. If using already-cooked prawns, follow their package reheating directions instead of the raw-prawn method below.
Take the steak out only when you are ready to prepare it; there is no need for a long room-temperature wait. Pat dry with paper towel and season with salt and pepper or spices. Wash hands and use separate utensils and boards for raw meat, seafood and salad.
02 / Cook the steak
Heat a suitable frying pan over medium-high heat. Add a little olive oil, or use butter at a heat that will not burn it. Put in the steaks without crowding the pan. Brown each side, turn as needed and adjust the heat to cook the centre without scorching the outside. If using butter, lower the heat as needed and spoon it over the steak.
Thickness and cut change the cooking time, so use a food thermometer rather than a fixed timer. For this guide, cook whole-cut steak to at least 63°C, then rest for at least 3 minutes on a clean plate. Mechanically tenderized steaks need particular care: follow the label and turn at least twice during cooking. Ground-beef patties need 71°C and are not interchangeable with a whole steak.
03 / Garlic-butter prawns
While the steak rests, melt the prawn butter in a separate pan over medium heat. If using onion, soften it first. Add the garlic and stir briefly until fragrant, without letting it burn. Add the drained raw prawns in a single layer, turn them and cook until the flesh is opaque and firm and the thickest part reaches 74°C. Remove from the heat once cooked rather than leaving them to toughen in the pan.
The shell-on version is peel-at-the-table food. Provide a small bowl for shells and napkins. If you prefer to peel and devein before cooking, adjust the cooking time and still check doneness. Keep shellfish and its utensils away from food prepared for someone with a shellfish allergy.
BUILD THE REST OF THE PLATE
Colin’s side options include Caesar salad, Greek salad, double-stuffed potatoes, Alfredo pasta and onions. Choose one or two rather than treating them as a compulsory list.
Start potatoes first if they need baking. Prepare salad components while the hot food cooks, keeping them separate from raw meat and seafood. Time pasta and sauce close to serving. Plate the steak and prawns last.
Galley English
“Would you like steak and prawns, or just one?”
“Does anyone have a shellfish allergy?”
“Which sides would you like?”
“The steak is resting. I’m finishing the prawns.”
- WANT TO: I want to get the meal ready together.
- HAVE TO: I have to check for allergies.
- NEED TO: I need to start the potatoes first.
- MIGHT: I might serve a Greek salad.
Serve promptly. Refrigerate leftovers in shallow containers within two hours. For cooking-temperature guidance, see Health Canada’s safe internal cooking temperatures.


