Colin Lee MacLeod — More Better Good
MENU ☰

How to Check Questionable Information

Check the claim. Trace the evidence. Leave room to change your mind.

Conceptual illustration of two adults comparing an original document with information on a laptop
AI-created conceptual illustration of fictional adults.

Adapted from the Miles Ember editorial draft for More Better Good.

A confident post, a dramatic clip, or advice from someone you admire can leave you with a decision: believe it, share it, act on it, or check it.

Start with one question:

What exactly is being claimed, and what would count as good evidence for it?

Our editorial position is that checking a claim should preserve people’s dignity. You can question information without insulting the person who shared it. You can change your mind without treating an earlier mistake as a verdict on your intelligence. The useful outcome is a more accurate understanding and a better next decision.

Throughout this article, research evidence describes findings from a study, professional guidance describes published verification practices, and editorial guidance offers our suggested ways to apply them. The examples are hypothetical.

1. Separate claims, evidence, and opinion

Use these working distinctions:

Kind of statement Hypothetical example How to handle it
Factual claim “The workshop starts at 10 a.m. on Monday.” Check the current schedule, date, location, and time zone.
Evidence A dated schedule supplied by the organizer. Check its authenticity, relevance, and whether a newer version exists.
Interpretation “Low attendance means nobody cares.” Examine the reasoning and other possible explanations.
Opinion or preference “An evening workshop would be better.” Ask better for whom, and according to which priorities.
Feeling or personal experience “I felt disappointed by the turnout.” Acknowledge the experience; examine any accompanying claims separately.

A factual claim is something that can be checked; calling it factual does not make it correct. Evidence is the material used to assess it. An opinion may contain factual assumptions that still need checking.

“I cannot verify this” and “I have evidence this is false” are different conclusions. A wrong statement also does not, by itself, establish an intention to deceive.

2. Begin with four practical checks

Professional guidance: Mike Caulfield’s SIFT framework offers four moves: stop, investigate the source, find better coverage, and trace claims and media to their original context. This checklist adapts those moves. SIFT framework

  1. Pause. Identify the precise claim before reacting or sharing.
  2. Investigate the source. Use other sources to check who is behind it and their relevant expertise.
  3. Look beyond the post. Find coverage that supplies evidence and explains uncertainty.
  4. Find the original context. Follow quotations, numbers, pictures, and clips back to the underlying material.

Research evidence: In a 2021 study at one university, 136 students received a curriculum teaching lateral reading—checking beyond the page in front of them—and 94 received comparison instruction. At the later assessment, instructed students were more likely to use lateral reading and correctly assess online information. The classes were matched by instructor. The findings support teaching these skills in that setting; they do not establish that a short checklist guarantees accuracy or that improvement lasts indefinitely. Read the study

3. Make the claim specific enough to check

Editorial guidance: Copy the important sentence. Underline words carrying a large promise: everyone, always, guaranteed, proven, free.

Then ask what the sentence commits the speaker to. Who is included? Which place and time? What conditions apply? What result is being promised?

Hypothetical example: A training advertisement says:

“Complete this course and you are guaranteed a job within 30 days.”

A useful check would examine the provider’s current written terms. Does “job” mean paid employment, an interview, or access to listings? When do the 30 days start? What must the learner do? Who makes the guarantee?

If the terms explicitly say employment is not guaranteed, that contradicts the advertisement.

If you cannot find any terms addressing the guarantee, the claim remains unsupported by the material you found. That is a reason to withhold confidence and ask for clarification; it is not proof that no supporting document exists.

Write the narrow conclusion your evidence permits:

“The terms contradict the advertised guarantee.”

That identifies the discrepancy without asserting why it happened.

4. Check whether confirmation is independent

Professional practice: AFP says it requires at least two independent sources to verify the central claim of a fact-check. That is an example of a newsroom standard; a source count alone cannot settle every question. AFP verification methods

Editorial guidance: Follow the evidence chain. If five articles all cite the same company announcement, you have five repetitions of one underlying account. Ask whether another source independently examined records, gathered data, or witnessed the event.

Give each source credit for what it can establish. An organizer’s current notice is direct evidence of its announced schedule. Its own praise for its event does not independently establish that the event is excellent.

Apply the same questions to a source you like and one you dislike. A financial interest is relevant context, but it does not automatically make a statement false. Credentials help identify relevant expertise; the specific claim still needs support.

5. Examine pictures, numbers, and AI answers

Pictures and video

Professional guidance: AFP checks original media and its context. It warns that a reverse-image search may find nothing because an image is unpublished or unindexed. A missing match therefore does not prove authenticity. AFP also requires evidence beyond an AI detector’s output. AFP verification methods

Editorial guidance: For a dramatic image, investigate the alleged date and location as well as whether the image itself is authentic. For a clip, look for the longer recording. For a quotation, read the surrounding passage.

Even an authentic photograph does not automatically establish everything in its caption.

Numbers

Editorial guidance: Write down the denominator, unit, and time period. Check whether a chart uses comparable groups and whether its vertical axis changes the visual impression.

Hypothetical calculation: A rate increasing from 2 out of 100 to 4 out of 100 has doubled. It has also risen by 2 percentage points. Both descriptions are mathematically correct. Having both lets you judge the scale.

AI answers

Evidence: NIST documents that generative AI can produce confident false statements and invented supporting citations. Its guidance includes checking sources and citations in generated output. NIST guidance

Editorial guidance: Use an AI answer as a starting point for questions. Open important references, confirm that the source exists, and check whether its text supports the exact claim. A real paper can still be cited for something it never found.

Asking the same system to reassure you is not independent corroboration.

A useful instruction is:

“Separate established findings, assumptions, and unanswered questions. Link the original sources for claims that matter.”

Then inspect those sources yourself.

6. Choose a conclusion that fits the evidence

These are editorial labels for a personal checking note:

Conclusion What it means
Supported within a stated scope The evidence supports this wording, population, place, and time.
Misleading or missing context Some material may be accurate, but omitted context changes the impression.
Contradicted Relevant, credible evidence conflicts with the claim.
Unresolved or insufficiently supported The available evidence does not justify a confident conclusion.
Opinion or value judgment Identify the priorities behind it and check factual premises separately.

For a prediction, examine its evidence, assumptions, and uncertainty. Keep a forecast distinct from an outcome already observed.

Do not use “unresolved” to manufacture doubt where strong evidence already answers the question. Equally, disagreement alone does not mean two positions have equal support.

Keep a short record:

  • Exact claim: What am I checking?
  • Best evidence: Where did it come from, and when?
  • Conclusion and limit: What does it establish, and what remains unknown?
  • Next decision: Share with context, ask for evidence, correct, or set aside.

For decisions affecting money, health, safety, or someone’s reputation, give unresolved details more attention and consult the relevant authoritative service or qualified person.

You can decline to share a claim without solving every question about it.

7. Correct mistakes plainly and kindly

Professional practice: Full Fact marks corrections on its articles and shares major corrections through the channels used for the original fact-check. Full Fact corrections policy

Editorial guidance: When you shared the error, make the correction easy for the same audience to find. State the accurate information, explain the relevant mistake, and provide the source.

Suggested wording:

“Correction: the workshop is on Tuesday. I shared an older schedule that said Monday. The organizer’s current notice is here. I’m sorry for the confusion.”

When checking something another person shared:

“I want to get this right. Do you have the original source? The record I found says something different. We may be looking at different dates.”

These are suggested communication choices, not promises about how someone will respond. You can set a boundary or leave a discussion if it becomes hostile.

My editorial view: Updating a belief is something to respect. Take responsibility for what the evidence now shows, and leave room to learn more.

Five linked source references rechecked November 16, 2026.

Make one careful check.

Choose one claim you were about to share. Find its original source and write only the conclusion the evidence supports.

Share feedback on this article →
The Four Finger Rule. Real life. Real conversations. Explore the Four Finger Rule.