Colin Lee MacLeod — More Better Good
MENU ☰

A U.S. Stock Can Rise While Its Canadian-Dollar Value Falls

Explore currency risk with a hypothetical CAD–USD worksheet. See why a rising U.S. share price can still produce a lower Canadian-dollar value.

Two currencies mean two measurements. Keep the labels on every number.

Hypothetical holding grows from US$2,000 to US$2,200, while exchange rates move from 1.40 to 1.25 CAD per USD; Canadian value falls from C$2,800 to C$2,750.
Original classroom diagram. Invented rates and prices, not current quotations. No fees, taxes or dividends in this example.

ROWAN VALE • ADULT FINANCIAL FOUNDATIONS

Classroom scope: General financial education, not personalized investment or tax advice. Every price, exchange rate and outcome here is hypothetical, not a current quote or forecast. No real security, currency trade or brokerage account is involved.

“It went up ten per cent” sounds complete. For a Canadian measuring an unhedged U.S. holding in Canadian dollars, it leaves out a second moving part: the exchange rate. The share can rise in U.S. dollars while the holding falls in Canadian-dollar value.

The Ontario Securities Commission’s investor education site describes currency risk as the possibility of loss from exchange-rate changes, including a U.S. investment becoming worth less in Canadian dollars. See why risk matters in investing.

Write the direction before doing the calculation

In this worksheet, every exchange rate means Canadian dollars per one U.S. dollar. A rate of 1.40 means US$1 is equivalent to C$1.40. Multiplying a USD holding by that rate converts its value to CAD.

If the rate falls from 1.40 to 1.25, each U.S. dollar becomes worth fewer Canadian dollars. Do not switch midway to the reciprocal quote, USD per CAD. If you encounter the opposite convention, convert it or change the calculation explicitly.

The fictional 100-share holding

Imagine 100 shares bought at US$20 each when US$1 equals C$1.40. Later the shares are valued at US$22 each, but US$1 equals only C$1.25. Assume no dividends, taxes, fees, additional deposits or withdrawals.

Beginning value

100 × US$20 = US$2,000.
US$2,000 × C$1.40 per US$1 = C$2,800.

Ending value

100 × US$22 = US$2,200.
US$2,200 × C$1.25 per US$1 = C$2,750.

The stock’s USD price increased 10%. The holding’s CAD value changed by C$2,750 − C$2,800 = −C$50, a return of about −1.79%. Both statements can be true. A valuation change can be calculated without selling; cash received on an eventual sale depends on actual execution and charges.

Why simply adding percentages is wrong

The exchange-rate factor is 1.25 ÷ 1.40, or approximately 0.892857. The USD investment-value factor is 2,200 ÷ 2,000, or 1.10. For this no-cash-flow example:

CAD return = (1.10 × 1.25 ÷ 1.40) − 1
= −0.017857…, or approximately −1.79%.

Adding the 10% stock gain to the roughly −10.71% exchange-rate change would miss their interaction. Converting the beginning and ending values separately is often the clearest way to avoid that mistake.

Keep exchange-rate movement separate from conversion charges

A changing exchange rate and a provider’s charge are different things. A markup may already be built into the rate offered, while an explicit fee may be charged separately. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada explains currency conversion markups. Check both the rate and separately billed amounts rather than assuming “no commission” means no cost.

Here is a separate arithmetic exercise, not a provider quote. Start with C$1,000 of equivalent value. Deduct a hypothetical 2% conversion charge, then another 2% of the remaining value on conversion back, with no market or exchange-rate change:

C$1,000 × 0.98 × 0.98 = C$960.40. The combined deduction is C$39.60, not exactly C$40, because the second percentage applies to a smaller amount. Real providers can use different methods.

If an actual conversion rate already incorporates the markup, do not deduct the same markup again. Keep the trade confirmation or conversion record so another person can reconstruct the calculation.

Try three variations

  1. Keep the ending US$2,200 value but change the ending exchange rate to C$1.50 per US$1. What is the CAD return?
  2. Keep the share price unchanged at US$20 but use the ending rate of C$1.25. What is the ending CAD value?
  3. Can the original example tell you whether a U.S. stock or a currency will rise next week?

Answers: C$3,300 ending value, C$500 gain, approximately +17.86%; C$2,500, or C$300 less than the initial C$2,800; no. A worked example demonstrates arithmetic, not forecasting ability.

A research note worth keeping

Record the measurement currency, beginning and ending dates, share quantities, prices, exchange-rate direction and source, actual conversion terms, and excluded items. Dividends, cash flows, hedging arrangements and taxes introduce additional work. Do not silently apply this simple two-date formula to a more complicated account.

The point is not to predict the Canadian dollar. It is to stop mistaking a gain in one unit of measurement for a guaranteed gain in another.

Adapted from Lesson 17 of Rowan Vale Financial Foundations, Volume 3. Rowan Vale is a fictional educational voice. Primary references checked November 16, 2026. Calculations independently rechecked; all scenarios are hypothetical.

Finish with a checkable explanation.

Keep your inputs, units and assumptions beside the answer. Name what the calculation cannot tell you. No investment or brokerage account is needed to complete this lesson.

Try a free English conversation lesson →
The Four Finger Rule. Real life. Real conversations. Explore the Four Finger Rule.